15 octobre 2012 01:15 ShaunHoggan Porteur du Projet
Thanks to all the designers who put so much work and thought into this logo design. The quality was so good from every designer that the decision of which direction to go was extremly difficult. The method of selection was put out to vote by our customers and while the results were mixed, they did lean towards a paticular style.
Special thanks to everyones quick responce to my requests at the last moment of debating so many alternatives. Everyone put in so much hard work in developing the final product. I could not be happier and know that each designer had a winning product at the end of the day.
Ultimately there is only one winner and in this process the winner was drafts 121 and 122 because of it's simplicity, ease to print on shirts or other physical media. The Logo also did not have geographical constraints in the design which was a minor yet important concern.
Best of luck to everyone involved in the process.
13 octobre 2012 18:58 ShaunHoggan Porteur du Projet
77 removed in preference for 76.
13 octobre 2012 18:29 ShaunHoggan Porteur du Projet
74, eliminated due to red color
13 octobre 2012 17:46 ShaunHoggan Porteur du Projet
39, eliminated due to too dark of green color. With a lighter color of green it may work.
13 octobre 2012 17:34 ShaunHoggan Porteur du Projet
63, after long debate, 63 is just not a winner... I am conflicted on this one, all external feedback says that the RED is killing it.
13 octobre 2012 17:25 ShaunHoggan Porteur du Projet
35, eliminated in preference of 73
13 octobre 2012 17:12 ShaunHoggan Porteur du Projet
Positive feedback to why I am eliminating drafts:
72, eliminated because of text and the graphic seems to thick
71, eliminated because of text and the graphic seems to thick
70, eliminated because of preference of text on 69 (more custom)
68, eliminated because of Grey text color and grey sphere
67, eliminated because color scheme of 66 looks more high tech
64, eliminated because, it should be combined with 65 (Please)
62, eliminated because it is nearly the same thing as 61, shorten choices for customers
60, eliminated because of preference for colors in 61
59, eliminated because, it is the same as 61
58, eliminated because it is the same as 59, shorten list for customers
57, eliminated because it is similar as 60
56, eliminated because it is similar as 60
54, eliminated because it is similar as 60
55, eliminated because it is similar as 60
53, cool but colors are not working
52, colors are not working
51, eliminated in preference of 44
50, Colors don't "POP" off the screen
48, eliminated in preference for 35
47, Eliminated in preference for 35
49, Eliminated because of preference for 48, also prefer long graphic to be green (not blue)
46, eliminated just because it likely will not work in the end
45, eliminated in preference for 46
43, eliminated in preference for 35
41, eliminated in preference for 61
40, eliminated in preference for 39
37, eliminated in preference for 35
36, eliminated in preference for 35
33, eliminated because of . after Mt.
32, eliminated because of . after Mt.
28, eliminated because of . after Mt.
27, eliminated because of . after Mt.
26, eliminated because of . after Mt.
25, eliminated because of multiple dashes hard to print on tee shirt and dot after Mt
22, eliminated in preference of 63
19, eliminated in preference of 63
17, eliminated in preference of 39
16, eliminated in preference of 39
14, eliminated in preference of 39
11, eliminated in preference of 39
10, eliminated in preference of 39
5, eliminated in preference of 39
4, eliminated in preference of 39
1, eliminated due to text choice.
Love:
69, simple arcs, custom text, small ".net"
Requests:
65, 64 combined into one... one for print, one for web
63, need non 3D versions for print, swap the green and red colors
60, 61, if picked will need multiple versions including 3D (web) and
44, change the . in the "i" to be blue (not green)
13 octobre 2012 16:00 ShaunHoggan Porteur du Projet
Designers,
we are getting super close to the end of the project and I need to really narrow down the choices for my customers.
You will notice that I am going to cut out a whole bunch of designs today (more so than usual) so that the choices are easier for my customers to pick from.
Just because I eliminate the design, does not mean that I don't like components of your design, it just means that there are others that are closer to the look we are seeking.
Seriously, I could not be happier with ALL of the drafts!!! they are so good!!!!
13 octobre 2012 15:56 ShaunHoggan Porteur du Projet
FiddlinNita, 25 is popular but I am going to need to eliminate it because of the dot after the mt plus the multiple 3 lines, while popular, are going to be more difficult to sew on a shirt...
13 octobre 2012 15:44 ShaunHoggan Porteur du Projet
Designers,
I sent out a request 2 days ago for my customers to vote on the drafts thus far. I have received the most votes for the following drafts
25, 35
Since then, there have been many changes / additions.
Drafts 43 - 69 are better than anything I have seen so I am going to send out another request for customers to vote again.
The final decision will lean towards something that has a couple of drafts that will look good on the web (3D, shadow, etc) Printed in black and white, and also has the ability to be simple to sew on a hat, or screen print on a shirt meaning lots of little details may be eliminated by virtue of their difficulty in replicating on multiple medias (fabric etc...)
Everyone has done such a great job and it will be difficult to pick a single draft at the end of the day. Thank you for all of your hard work thus far.
13 octobre 2012 13:09 ShaunHoggan Porteur du Projet
10 octobre 2012 12:39 ShaunHoggan Porteur du Projet
FiddlinNita,
Drafts 25,26,27
LOVE LOVE LOVE the waves above the text. LOVE the colors, NOT in love with the text or font of MtWire.net
10 octobre 2012 03:53 ShaunHoggan Porteur du Projet
Schary,
Draft 17,
Love the wave, Thinking at this point the sizzors are a bad idea. I prefer the quarter sized lines comming off the "i" in draft 19. The smaller radiating lines comming off of the .net are not doing it for me.
10 octobre 2012 03:45 ShaunHoggan Porteur du Projet
Draft 20
DraftAngel, can you split the M and W so there is a gap between them? Plus the shading on the ".net" is hard to read. Prefer the solid color on draft 19 for the ".net"
Cool work!!!
9 octobre 2012 11:49 ShaunHoggan Porteur du Projet
(Draft 19)
DraftAngel,
love the lines comming off the i at an angle. love the .net with the alternating color comming off at an angle.
I also like the opposing M and W. Great use of the two letters on top of each other. While I dont think this is the end all of the logo, you may be on to something big. What if there were a line between the M and W removing all the text including mtwire.net so instead of having the lettering of mtwire.net it was just the M and W opposing each other. Great work!
25 Commentaire récents
Porteur du Projet
Special thanks to everyones quick responce to my requests at the last moment of debating so many alternatives. Everyone put in so much hard work in developing the final product. I could not be happier and know that each designer had a winning product at the end of the day.
Ultimately there is only one winner and in this process the winner was drafts 121 and 122 because of it's simplicity, ease to print on shirts or other physical media. The Logo also did not have geographical constraints in the design which was a minor yet important concern.
Best of luck to everyone involved in the process.
Porteur du Projet
Porteur du Projet
Porteur du Projet
Porteur du Projet
Porteur du Projet
Porteur du Projet
72, eliminated because of text and the graphic seems to thick
71, eliminated because of text and the graphic seems to thick
70, eliminated because of preference of text on 69 (more custom)
68, eliminated because of Grey text color and grey sphere
67, eliminated because color scheme of 66 looks more high tech
64, eliminated because, it should be combined with 65 (Please)
62, eliminated because it is nearly the same thing as 61, shorten choices for customers
60, eliminated because of preference for colors in 61
59, eliminated because, it is the same as 61
58, eliminated because it is the same as 59, shorten list for customers
57, eliminated because it is similar as 60
56, eliminated because it is similar as 60
54, eliminated because it is similar as 60
55, eliminated because it is similar as 60
53, cool but colors are not working
52, colors are not working
51, eliminated in preference of 44
50, Colors don't "POP" off the screen
48, eliminated in preference for 35
47, Eliminated in preference for 35
49, Eliminated because of preference for 48, also prefer long graphic to be green (not blue)
46, eliminated just because it likely will not work in the end
45, eliminated in preference for 46
43, eliminated in preference for 35
41, eliminated in preference for 61
40, eliminated in preference for 39
37, eliminated in preference for 35
36, eliminated in preference for 35
33, eliminated because of . after Mt.
32, eliminated because of . after Mt.
28, eliminated because of . after Mt.
27, eliminated because of . after Mt.
26, eliminated because of . after Mt.
25, eliminated because of multiple dashes hard to print on tee shirt and dot after Mt
22, eliminated in preference of 63
19, eliminated in preference of 63
17, eliminated in preference of 39
16, eliminated in preference of 39
14, eliminated in preference of 39
11, eliminated in preference of 39
10, eliminated in preference of 39
5, eliminated in preference of 39
4, eliminated in preference of 39
1, eliminated due to text choice.
Love:
69, simple arcs, custom text, small ".net"
Requests:
65, 64 combined into one... one for print, one for web
63, need non 3D versions for print, swap the green and red colors
60, 61, if picked will need multiple versions including 3D (web) and
44, change the . in the "i" to be blue (not green)
Porteur du Projet
we are getting super close to the end of the project and I need to really narrow down the choices for my customers.
You will notice that I am going to cut out a whole bunch of designs today (more so than usual) so that the choices are easier for my customers to pick from.
Just because I eliminate the design, does not mean that I don't like components of your design, it just means that there are others that are closer to the look we are seeking.
Seriously, I could not be happier with ALL of the drafts!!! they are so good!!!!
Porteur du Projet
Porteur du Projet
I sent out a request 2 days ago for my customers to vote on the drafts thus far. I have received the most votes for the following drafts
25, 35
Since then, there have been many changes / additions.
Drafts 43 - 69 are better than anything I have seen so I am going to send out another request for customers to vote again.
The final decision will lean towards something that has a couple of drafts that will look good on the web (3D, shadow, etc) Printed in black and white, and also has the ability to be simple to sew on a hat, or screen print on a shirt meaning lots of little details may be eliminated by virtue of their difficulty in replicating on multiple medias (fabric etc...)
Everyone has done such a great job and it will be difficult to pick a single draft at the end of the day. Thank you for all of your hard work thus far.
Porteur du Projet
thanks
i'll work hard for this project , , ,
Porteur du Projet
Porteur du Projet
Draft 36, it has been suggested to add radiating lines comming from the . in .net. I am not so sure... but it could work.
Porteur du Projet
Like it alot!!!
Porteur du Projet
I love what you are doing! The only concern that I have is the logo should not contain a . after the Mt.
That dot is not really part of the logo I am loving drafts 25, 32, 33
Porteur du Projet
Drafts 25,26,27
LOVE LOVE LOVE the waves above the text. LOVE the colors, NOT in love with the text or font of MtWire.net
Porteur du Projet
Draft 17,
Love the wave, Thinking at this point the sizzors are a bad idea. I prefer the quarter sized lines comming off the "i" in draft 19. The smaller radiating lines comming off of the .net are not doing it for me.
Porteur du Projet
DraftAngel, can you split the M and W so there is a gap between them? Plus the shading on the ".net" is hard to read. Prefer the solid color on draft 19 for the ".net"
Cool work!!!
Porteur du Projet
DraftAngel,
love the lines comming off the i at an angle. love the .net with the alternating color comming off at an angle.
I also like the opposing M and W. Great use of the two letters on top of each other. While I dont think this is the end all of the logo, you may be on to something big. What if there were a line between the M and W removing all the text including mtwire.net so instead of having the lettering of mtwire.net it was just the M and W opposing each other. Great work!