Check out www.DesignCage.net its pretty awesome,you can win more contests.
13 septembre 2011 12:28 raremylove Porteur du Projet
We respect your opinion Carlo. And we appreciate it too.
We tried to get in touch with the designers personally to tweak the existing designs and went to the extent of printing them on a sample paper advertisement to see what suited best. there were some designs which looked great on display but not on paper. That is when we started tweaking the design requirements .
the project was extended with the sole purpose where we have mentioned in the comments section that we required group color related blue and something related to our logo. The existing graphic is not detailed, we know. But then the final submission would be of, I hope. Moeover, the image would be tweaked by our designers to suit our need. And the worm, is more of the concept of a bird flying forward which would be again changed at our end to look like one.
We really look forward to working with logo design guru again and next time we would ensure that the mistakes committed by us in this project unknowingly would not be committed again.
We apologize to any designers who felt that their hard work is being rejected or not considered worthwhile. This is not the case.
And I thought the selection was even more shocking. I didn't initiate anything. I am just asking a question that could be answered by yes or no. And I have nothing against anyone.
I'm just typing on behalf of the people who have worked hard to come up with a quality designs and works just to be dumped by someone carrying a rasterized "worm-like" image from mars.(FYI raster based graphics are not allowed to be posted as entry).
The design could have come from the ones with high ratings so they could have tweaked their designs to fit what you're looking for. I thought that's the reason why this contest was extended. Nevertheless, I believe they could have made a better looking worm.
13 septembre 2011 05:56 raremylove Porteur du Projet
in fact! we even propose that the same concept and the design be improved and the winner would be selected from the one who have participated and not any new entrant....
the existing winner would also be kept out of this loop....
if the website can permit to do so...
FYI : the top designs were from
Daphnee. Surabhi1308. GridR. Emenstudio. JvisulFlow, Creativepic and SIHEM.
also carlo, the same design was mentioned to you too and you were requested to work on it too and this inititation from your end came as a shock!
13 septembre 2011 05:30 raremylove Porteur du Projet
what a hatred response!
didnt expect this....
why would we guarantee the project in the first place if we didnt want to pay?
why is the resolution of the image an issue?
the final logo ould anyways be altered by our team.
why would indians come in to the pic?
surprising....
its not the worms nor the resolution, please read the concept behind the logo. we have even informed the designers that the same logo could be worked upon or the same concept could be improved upon....
This is ridiculous, Buyer open another fake ID and submit some crap and select himself a winner...b'coz this was the guaranteed project,if he won't do it then logoguru select high ranked designer.
Admin should take action on the basis of design selected and check the IP of both username,if they found guilty..cease the payment.
Is this a scam? There are so many great designs proposed for this project and the logo chosen is a low-res, hard to read, badly proportioned, out of direction kind of crap? Designed by a very dubious designer.
12 septembre 2011 01:26 raremylove Porteur du Projet
Hi All!
it has been a great time discussing with different designers and different concepts!
The talent pool is great ! through out the project stage the diff. concepts compelled us to rethink on our product logo concept!draft 428 was selected as the winning design, precisely for this reason.
it has been a great journey and we whole heartily thank all the designers for participating and spending their valuable time on the project.
6 septembre 2011 11:11 raremylove Porteur du Projet
Got the project extended for 3 more days!
designers.. please pour in.. we need to finalize now pretty quickly!
thanks
Rakesh
3 septembre 2011 13:04 raremylove Porteur du Projet
draft 263 is already used in India by Lanco company.
please remove...
thanks
rakesh
3 septembre 2011 02:58 raremylove Porteur du Projet
Hi all!
What great submissions!
We have the final list of drafts which match closely to our vision.
the concepts are great with specific changes.
the draft numbers are 238, 235, 209, 196, 120, 66, 7
Designers are requested to work on these draft concepts.
Individual designers would be sent specific changes required from these drafts...
Please mail us, for any clarifications.
thanks
Rakesh
1 septembre 2011 03:07 raremylove Porteur du Projet
Today, we have eliminated a lot of design drafts as it is not matching with our vision of the logo...
we have rated drafts entries with 1 and 2 stars. We like the concept but if the execution can be more close to our earlier comments where we have posted the requirements, then we can review and rate them better
entries with 4 to 5 stars, please check and submit revised drafts. Some drafts have been submitted only once and no revisions are being submitted in spite of requests.
All the participants, please do have a look at designs submitted with 4 to 5 stars, as it is closer to how we like the logo...
no designer has used the group logo color recently in an appealing way. please do look at the drafts with stars, they have some concepts which if perfected can be the winning design.
thanks
Rakesh
1 septembre 2011 02:27 raremylove Porteur du Projet
Hi all!
thanks again for the participation!
As how much we appreciate the talent, we would like to convey that a lot of the drafts are very similar to each other with the same concept.
We strictly do not encourage the same.
We want to see new design concepts....
this would make it more challenging for us to review and get the final logo better.
since we have some idea regarding the design after looking at the drafts ... we are posting some ques for you to work on...
1) the colors to use can be focused on the group logo colors(available on our website www.kamachigroup.com) . also, the color of hot molten liqated on the liquid steel(link already provided) and the color of the tmt (link already provided)
2) the design should focus only on the word kothari and not on tmt. this request is bein repeated as many designers have concentrated on the design of tmt.
3) the font needs to be tight placed to look more rugged and display strength
4)in all drafts please post both italics and bold only text designs for better comparison
5) * important* please implement if the design can include the liquid metal flowing in between or through the letters and forming a tmt bar on which we can write the tagline....
we request all the designers to post drafts with different concepts. we can have different design elements of drafts and combine to arrive at a favorable design!
We have also decided to evaluate designs on day basis and work on the best designs of the day with the designers. we feel this would help us evaluate better.
25 Commentaire récents
Porteur du Projet
We tried to get in touch with the designers personally to tweak the existing designs and went to the extent of printing them on a sample paper advertisement to see what suited best. there were some designs which looked great on display but not on paper. That is when we started tweaking the design requirements .
the project was extended with the sole purpose where we have mentioned in the comments section that we required group color related blue and something related to our logo. The existing graphic is not detailed, we know. But then the final submission would be of, I hope. Moeover, the image would be tweaked by our designers to suit our need. And the worm, is more of the concept of a bird flying forward which would be again changed at our end to look like one.
We really look forward to working with logo design guru again and next time we would ensure that the mistakes committed by us in this project unknowingly would not be committed again.
We apologize to any designers who felt that their hard work is being rejected or not considered worthwhile. This is not the case.
Thanks and regards
Rakesh
I'm just typing on behalf of the people who have worked hard to come up with a quality designs and works just to be dumped by someone carrying a rasterized "worm-like" image from mars.(FYI raster based graphics are not allowed to be posted as entry).
The design could have come from the ones with high ratings so they could have tweaked their designs to fit what you're looking for. I thought that's the reason why this contest was extended. Nevertheless, I believe they could have made a better looking worm.
Porteur du Projet
the existing winner would also be kept out of this loop....
if the website can permit to do so...
FYI : the top designs were from
Daphnee. Surabhi1308. GridR. Emenstudio. JvisulFlow, Creativepic and SIHEM.
also carlo, the same design was mentioned to you too and you were requested to work on it too and this inititation from your end came as a shock!
Porteur du Projet
didnt expect this....
why would we guarantee the project in the first place if we didnt want to pay?
why is the resolution of the image an issue?
the final logo ould anyways be altered by our team.
why would indians come in to the pic?
surprising....
its not the worms nor the resolution, please read the concept behind the logo. we have even informed the designers that the same logo could be worked upon or the same concept could be improved upon....
I think It was not an idea..... But it was a plan........
I agreed
Admin should take action on the basis of design selected and check the IP of both username,if they found guilty..cease the payment.
or is this a joke project????
Porteur du Projet
it has been a great time discussing with different designers and different concepts!
The talent pool is great ! through out the project stage the diff. concepts compelled us to rethink on our product logo concept!draft 428 was selected as the winning design, precisely for this reason.
it has been a great journey and we whole heartily thank all the designers for participating and spending their valuable time on the project.
we wish to work with you guys again soon!
thanks
Rakesh
Porteur du Projet
designers.. please pour in.. we need to finalize now pretty quickly!
thanks
Rakesh
Porteur du Projet
please remove...
thanks
rakesh
Porteur du Projet
What great submissions!
We have the final list of drafts which match closely to our vision.
the concepts are great with specific changes.
the draft numbers are 238, 235, 209, 196, 120, 66, 7
Designers are requested to work on these draft concepts.
Individual designers would be sent specific changes required from these drafts...
Please mail us, for any clarifications.
thanks
Rakesh
Porteur du Projet
we have rated drafts entries with 1 and 2 stars. We like the concept but if the execution can be more close to our earlier comments where we have posted the requirements, then we can review and rate them better
entries with 4 to 5 stars, please check and submit revised drafts. Some drafts have been submitted only once and no revisions are being submitted in spite of requests.
All the participants, please do have a look at designs submitted with 4 to 5 stars, as it is closer to how we like the logo...
no designer has used the group logo color recently in an appealing way. please do look at the drafts with stars, they have some concepts which if perfected can be the winning design.
thanks
Rakesh
Porteur du Projet
thanks again for the participation!
As how much we appreciate the talent, we would like to convey that a lot of the drafts are very similar to each other with the same concept.
We strictly do not encourage the same.
We want to see new design concepts....
this would make it more challenging for us to review and get the final logo better.
please look into the same
regards
rakesh :)
Porteur du Projet
we have rated 4 stars to drafts which we feel are starting to look like our vision for the logo... Please do refer the same go get a better idea and
Yes! please keep the contributions coming! its good to know there's so much talent and we respect the same!
Regards
Rakesh
Porteur du Projet
Please find a picture of Kothari TMT @ this link
Thought this would be useful for your design..
thanks
Rakesh
Porteur du Projet
just uploaded a picture of Kothari TMT under "read brief" about the project.
This pic is for ref only. Please do not use it as it is.
Thanks
Rakesh
Porteur du Projet
since we have some idea regarding the design after looking at the drafts ... we are posting some ques for you to work on...
1) the colors to use can be focused on the group logo colors(available on our website www.kamachigroup.com) . also, the color of hot molten liqated on the liquid steel(link already provided) and the color of the tmt (link already provided)
2) the design should focus only on the word kothari and not on tmt. this request is bein repeated as many designers have concentrated on the design of tmt.
3) the font needs to be tight placed to look more rugged and display strength
4)in all drafts please post both italics and bold only text designs for better comparison
5) * important* please implement if the design can include the liquid metal flowing in between or through the letters and forming a tmt bar on which we can write the tagline....
thanks and regards to all
Rakesh
Porteur du Projet
We have also decided to evaluate designs on day basis and work on the best designs of the day with the designers. we feel this would help us evaluate better.
Suggestions/comments are highly appreciated!
thanks
Rakesh
Porteur du Projet
1) representative images of hot liquid metal pouring (image link)
http://www.bhamsandwich.com/pantry/wp-content/uploads/2008/11/iron.jpg
Also, The image of the liquid pouring( in golden color) can be used
The pouring can form a tmt which can be incorporated in the design