Thank you Everyone for your participation and efforts on this project. In the end, there will only be one winner and I really appreciate your hard work on this competition. The winner of this project is design #17 by uzumaki. This decision is based on a majority vote by my team of 8 people and design #17 was chosen 4 times. Congratulations on the victory Uzumaki ! :)
Dear designers as of now, 21 Feb 2011 6:35 pm Can Eastern Time, the top 3 design picks IN NO PARTICULAR ORDER are:
1. design #47 by Gududu
2. deisgn #16/#17 by uzumaki
3. design #1/#14 by Mambutzica
Great work on this. I will follow up on new designs asap. Thank you very much.
@ cubingbekletem #52:
Great work on creating a visual mark incorporating the element of the sun and the moon. Feedback is below.
(+) design looks quite sophisticated. Plays on lighting is excellent; it is not too overwhelming that it makes the logo look weak but it could be improved.
(-) "Entertainment Association" should not be italized to make it easier to read; keep it straight. visual mark, although looks modern, is very complicated - I would use 1 or two lines for the sunrays to keep it simple. Font selection for the writing "Cirque Entertainment Association" is not so good; i would keep it simple & profession. I prefer the font with Q that has 'long tail'. Color selection is poor; i'd prefer a color that is soft and bright so logo looks lively. I still perceive that there is some middle eastern element on the design which i don't really like.
Great work on this, i'd encourage you to make more submissions of another design. Overall design score: 3.5/4.0
@Spooniy #51,#53:
this is quite frankly the same one as the one you submitted before. only the color is different. however, i'll give you some feedback on this.
(+) Again, i love the woman in shadow. The two-stack lines of "Cirque Entertainment Association" is good.
(-) I was asking to incorporate the sun and moon element in an abstract kind of way: this one only the color seems a bit abstract. Color selection is poor; color is too dark. the dark shades (which resembles meteor falling from the sky) interfere with the simplicity of the design and should be omitted. the image of the moon inside the circle is poor and should be more integrated with creativity. No play on lighting which doesn't bring that sense of elegance on the logo.
Thank you very much on the efforts. Truly appreciate it. Overall design score: 2.5/5.0
@ Alexs74 #43, #49:
Great improvements from the previous designs but i encourage you to submit additional designs of the visual mark to compete with the other designers. I'll continually provide some feedback within 24 hrs before the due time.
(+) high point on simplicity and color selection. symbol conveys the club's theme. Excellent play on lighting of the logo; the logo looks very much lively in comparison to the previous one. logo is very catchy and easy to recognize.
(-) i'd prefer if the 'cirque entertainment association' to be stacked in two lines as opposed to three lines w/ the first line can being 'cirque'; second line being 'entertainment association'. Visual mark can be improved by incorporating more creative ideas.
Logo is well done, overall design score is 4.0/5.0.
@gududu #38-#40:
I don't know what you are trying to do with these logos because i perceive them as an incomplete logo (especially #39). I will make some critique on this. #38
(+) color selection is good. shadow placement is good.
(-) logo looks too simple and doesn't convey the whole idea of the club. It looks like a pokeball (in pokemon). it looks pretty generic.
overall design: 2.5/5.0
#39
(+) same as the one above.
(-) logo looks like an incomplete c. logo doesn't convey elegance. it doesn't look sophisticated.
overall design: 2.0/5.0
#40
(+) same as the one above.
(-) logo looks like a simple ball that doesn't convey the theme of the club. it doesn't look modern and stylish. It doesn't incorporate any element of the moon and the sun. Low point on creativity.
Overall design: 2.0/5.0
Great jobs. I really appreciate the work. thanks very much. RW
@gududu #37:
this is quite frankly similar to yours #28 but i'll give you a feed back on this.
(+) high point on simplicity of design. 2-color choice of read and white matches well with the design of the opaque square. shadows within the opaque square is well placed and the thickness of the shadows doesn't overwhelm the whole design. design conveys elegant and sophistication. i will give 4.0/5.0 on the design.
(-) visual mark doesn't incorporate the sun and the moon in a collaborative and creative way. The simple opaque square doesn't convey the theme of our club to targeted audience.
great work on this. overall design 4.0/5.0. Thanks a bunch.
@gududu #44-48:
of all these similar logos, my selection will be #46/47 #44, 45, and #48, the sun rays are inverted down. these inverted sun rays symbolizes a downfall and as a new club, we would like to rise above all the others which is why I prefer #44, #48. #44 & #48 the sun rises up and it literally means a success.
Below is the (+) and (-):
(+) symbol design is very well designed and stylish. it conveys sophistication and elegance with its simplicity. color of the wording "cirque entertainment association" is excellent, although i prefer "entertainment association" to be a bit bolder and sharper to make it more stand out and easier to read. I like the creativity with the sun rays bursting some shines from the moon. Design is a complete glamour and color selection is really good. 4.5/5.0 for design.
(-) the defiency of the logo is with the lighting and brightness. the lighting fades the sun rays to a point in which the visualization of the mark is impaired. excessive brightness, though make the logo elegant, makes the logo weak due to lack of clarity. lighting is 1/5
This is by far your best one. Great tremendous efforts. Truly appreciate it. Overall score: 4.0/5.0
@fabian #34:
(+) clean design. 3.7/5.0 on simplicity.
(-) visual mark looks generic. the incorporation of world geography inside the visual mark don't fit with the whole idea of cirque entertainment association. font selection is poor.
@spooniy #32,33,35,36:
(+) visual mark incorporating the sun and the moon is creative but it doesn't look elegant and sophisticated. color selection is relatively strong (due to its brightness). i love the shadow of the woman doing ballet.
(-) the placement of the "cirque" with "entertainment" & "association" is not justified. I'd love it if you can make the visual mark is more of an abstract one, you have the option of again: incorporating the moon/ the sun in an abstract kind of way while keeping it sophisticated.
if you choose a dark background, make the logo color bright inside the background. this is to make contrast.
@ uzumaki logo #31:
(+) VERY CLEAN design, very sophisticated, color is very strong and bright.high points on simplicity and elegance. the incorporation of the sun and the moon into the visual mark that resembles a nike logo is very creative and out-of-the box thinking. symbol is very intriguing and catchy. Definitely one of the best of all that's been submitted.
(-) the one with the white background, the spacing between the visual mark and "cirque" is too close; the placement is not the same as the one above it. other than that no complaint.
@cubingbekletem #29-#30:
(-) logo doesn't look sophisticated; looks very classic & have some sort of middle eastern elements embedded (especially within the fonts). the "entertainment association" is wiggling around which is hard to read. the transformed Q is certainly one creative point but it sort of impaired the legibility of the logo.
(+) clean design, not too much element incorporated. color is bright and clear.I'd love to have the creative element separated by having a visual logo/mark on the left side of the writing "Cirque Entertainment Association" to keep the "cirque entertainment association' legible.
@25-28 Gududu:
(+) symbol looks very elegant and versatile. High point on sophistication and simplicity. color selection is very strong.
(-)the visual logo (THE SQUARE) could be design more creatively. I would give the square 3.8/5.0.
@molteck:
(-) design doesn't convey elegance and versatility. design doesn't look sophisticated. The sun and the moon should be more creatively integrated. You can integrate the sun and the moon together into a separate visual logo beside the writing: Cirque Entertainment Association.
(+) I like the Q with the long tail.
@alexs74 #22,23:
(+) The design is very simple, yet very versatile. Logo is easy to read and easy to remember. i love the integration of the sun and the moon into the logo which resembles a person.
(-) Color is solemn/ doesn't stand out. if you pick orange, i'd prefer to have a brighter orange and not mix the orange w/ black or other dark color. line divider is unnecessary; it hinders the flow of the logo. overall design: 3.5/5
@gududu #18,19,20:
(-) the thing about the design is that it's too complicated and people will not easily remember it. There is so many elements on the design from the sunrays to the background for the I (which i think represent a moon) which could be simplified. The symbol is hard to read. color selection is poor.
(+) you have better chance with your symbol #25-#28. they look elegant.
@alexs74 #21
(+) great integration of the moon & the sun. great ideas and creativity involved.
(-) 1. color is inconsistent (too colorful; a choice of 2 or 3 colors would be better to convey the meaning of the symbol). 2. The design of the sun symbol for Q is to excessive. People may fault the Q as being a sun, and read the logo CIR UE. 3. symbol doesn't convey simplicity and sophistication. 4. symbol doesn't look professional. overall 2/5. your logo #22/ #23 looks much better.
@uzumaki:
(+) great logo, great creativity, color is very sophisticated.
(-) lack of spacing between cirque and entertainment association needed. it looked too jam packed.
I wonder if you can propose one with another font for the Cirque. I'd love one with 'Q' with a long tail. Also, more vertical spacing between the Cirque and Entertainment association, but not too much.
25 Commentaire récents
Sincere Thanks,
uzumaki
@elements: thank you..
elements
Porteur du Projet
is really that your creation? because i found a logo that looks exactly like your on a poker website
http://www.pokeronlinea.it/images/betclic-lrg-icon.gif
Porteur du Projet
I like you designs, especially #67. Could you please submit an alternative on a white background. Thanks.
Porteur du Projet
1. design #47 by Gududu
2. deisgn #16/#17 by uzumaki
3. design #1/#14 by Mambutzica
Great work on this. I will follow up on new designs asap. Thank you very much.
RW
Porteur du Projet
Great work on creating a visual mark incorporating the element of the sun and the moon. Feedback is below.
(+) design looks quite sophisticated. Plays on lighting is excellent; it is not too overwhelming that it makes the logo look weak but it could be improved.
(-) "Entertainment Association" should not be italized to make it easier to read; keep it straight. visual mark, although looks modern, is very complicated - I would use 1 or two lines for the sunrays to keep it simple. Font selection for the writing "Cirque Entertainment Association" is not so good; i would keep it simple & profession. I prefer the font with Q that has 'long tail'. Color selection is poor; i'd prefer a color that is soft and bright so logo looks lively. I still perceive that there is some middle eastern element on the design which i don't really like.
Great work on this, i'd encourage you to make more submissions of another design. Overall design score: 3.5/4.0
Porteur du Projet
this is quite frankly the same one as the one you submitted before. only the color is different. however, i'll give you some feedback on this.
(+) Again, i love the woman in shadow. The two-stack lines of "Cirque Entertainment Association" is good.
(-) I was asking to incorporate the sun and moon element in an abstract kind of way: this one only the color seems a bit abstract. Color selection is poor; color is too dark. the dark shades (which resembles meteor falling from the sky) interfere with the simplicity of the design and should be omitted. the image of the moon inside the circle is poor and should be more integrated with creativity. No play on lighting which doesn't bring that sense of elegance on the logo.
Thank you very much on the efforts. Truly appreciate it. Overall design score: 2.5/5.0
Porteur du Projet
Great improvements from the previous designs but i encourage you to submit additional designs of the visual mark to compete with the other designers. I'll continually provide some feedback within 24 hrs before the due time.
(+) high point on simplicity and color selection. symbol conveys the club's theme. Excellent play on lighting of the logo; the logo looks very much lively in comparison to the previous one. logo is very catchy and easy to recognize.
(-) i'd prefer if the 'cirque entertainment association' to be stacked in two lines as opposed to three lines w/ the first line can being 'cirque'; second line being 'entertainment association'. Visual mark can be improved by incorporating more creative ideas.
Logo is well done, overall design score is 4.0/5.0.
Porteur du Projet
Porteur du Projet
I don't know what you are trying to do with these logos because i perceive them as an incomplete logo (especially #39). I will make some critique on this.
#38
(+) color selection is good. shadow placement is good.
(-) logo looks too simple and doesn't convey the whole idea of the club. It looks like a pokeball (in pokemon). it looks pretty generic.
overall design: 2.5/5.0
#39
(+) same as the one above.
(-) logo looks like an incomplete c. logo doesn't convey elegance. it doesn't look sophisticated.
overall design: 2.0/5.0
#40
(+) same as the one above.
(-) logo looks like a simple ball that doesn't convey the theme of the club. it doesn't look modern and stylish. It doesn't incorporate any element of the moon and the sun. Low point on creativity.
Overall design: 2.0/5.0
Great jobs. I really appreciate the work. thanks very much. RW
Porteur du Projet
this is quite frankly similar to yours #28 but i'll give you a feed back on this.
(+) high point on simplicity of design. 2-color choice of read and white matches well with the design of the opaque square. shadows within the opaque square is well placed and the thickness of the shadows doesn't overwhelm the whole design. design conveys elegant and sophistication. i will give 4.0/5.0 on the design.
(-) visual mark doesn't incorporate the sun and the moon in a collaborative and creative way. The simple opaque square doesn't convey the theme of our club to targeted audience.
great work on this. overall design 4.0/5.0. Thanks a bunch.
Porteur du Projet
of all these similar logos, my selection will be #46/47
#44, 45, and #48, the sun rays are inverted down. these inverted sun rays symbolizes a downfall and as a new club, we would like to rise above all the others which is why I prefer #44, #48. #44 & #48 the sun rises up and it literally means a success.
Below is the (+) and (-):
(+) symbol design is very well designed and stylish. it conveys sophistication and elegance with its simplicity. color of the wording "cirque entertainment association" is excellent, although i prefer "entertainment association" to be a bit bolder and sharper to make it more stand out and easier to read. I like the creativity with the sun rays bursting some shines from the moon. Design is a complete glamour and color selection is really good. 4.5/5.0 for design.
(-) the defiency of the logo is with the lighting and brightness. the lighting fades the sun rays to a point in which the visualization of the mark is impaired. excessive brightness, though make the logo elegant, makes the logo weak due to lack of clarity. lighting is 1/5
This is by far your best one. Great tremendous efforts. Truly appreciate it. Overall score: 4.0/5.0
Porteur du Projet
as of now the top 3 selection IN NO PARTICULAR ORDER IS:
1. Design #1/#14 by Mambutzica
2. Design #31 by Uzumaki
3. Design #16/#17 by Uzumaki
Thank you very much for all the great efforts. I will make my decision asap as soon as the contest is finished.
Porteur du Projet
(+) clean design. 3.7/5.0 on simplicity.
(-) visual mark looks generic. the incorporation of world geography inside the visual mark don't fit with the whole idea of cirque entertainment association. font selection is poor.
great job. overall mark 2.5/5.0
Porteur du Projet
(+) visual mark incorporating the sun and the moon is creative but it doesn't look elegant and sophisticated. color selection is relatively strong (due to its brightness). i love the shadow of the woman doing ballet.
(-) the placement of the "cirque" with "entertainment" & "association" is not justified. I'd love it if you can make the visual mark is more of an abstract one, you have the option of again: incorporating the moon/ the sun in an abstract kind of way while keeping it sophisticated.
if you choose a dark background, make the logo color bright inside the background. this is to make contrast.
Great job and efforts, overall design: 3/5.
Porteur du Projet
(+) VERY CLEAN design, very sophisticated, color is very strong and bright.high points on simplicity and elegance. the incorporation of the sun and the moon into the visual mark that resembles a nike logo is very creative and out-of-the box thinking. symbol is very intriguing and catchy. Definitely one of the best of all that's been submitted.
(-) the one with the white background, the spacing between the visual mark and "cirque" is too close; the placement is not the same as the one above it. other than that no complaint.
great job indeed. overall 4.3/5.0
Porteur du Projet
(-) logo doesn't look sophisticated; looks very classic & have some sort of middle eastern elements embedded (especially within the fonts). the "entertainment association" is wiggling around which is hard to read. the transformed Q is certainly one creative point but it sort of impaired the legibility of the logo.
(+) clean design, not too much element incorporated. color is bright and clear.I'd love to have the creative element separated by having a visual logo/mark on the left side of the writing "Cirque Entertainment Association" to keep the "cirque entertainment association' legible.
Great efforts. overall 3/5
Porteur du Projet
As of now, my top 3 picks IN NO PARTICULAR ORDER IS:
DESIGN #16/#17 by Uzumaki
DESIGN #27/#28 by Gududu
DESIGN #1/#14 by Mambutzica
excellent jobs. truly appreciate them. I will decide in 1 more day. thank you.
Porteur du Projet
(+) symbol looks very elegant and versatile. High point on sophistication and simplicity. color selection is very strong.
(-)the visual logo (THE SQUARE) could be design more creatively. I would give the square 3.8/5.0.
excellent job. overall design: 4.0/5.0
Porteur du Projet
(-) design doesn't convey elegance and versatility. design doesn't look sophisticated. The sun and the moon should be more creatively integrated. You can integrate the sun and the moon together into a separate visual logo beside the writing: Cirque Entertainment Association.
(+) I like the Q with the long tail.
Good try, truly appreciate it. overall design 2/5
Porteur du Projet
(+) The design is very simple, yet very versatile. Logo is easy to read and easy to remember. i love the integration of the sun and the moon into the logo which resembles a person.
(-) Color is solemn/ doesn't stand out. if you pick orange, i'd prefer to have a brighter orange and not mix the orange w/ black or other dark color. line divider is unnecessary; it hinders the flow of the logo. overall design: 3.5/5
Porteur du Projet
(-) the thing about the design is that it's too complicated and people will not easily remember it. There is so many elements on the design from the sunrays to the background for the I (which i think represent a moon) which could be simplified. The symbol is hard to read. color selection is poor.
(+) you have better chance with your symbol #25-#28. they look elegant.
overall design for #18,19,20: 2/5
Porteur du Projet
(+) great integration of the moon & the sun. great ideas and creativity involved.
(-) 1. color is inconsistent (too colorful; a choice of 2 or 3 colors would be better to convey the meaning of the symbol). 2. The design of the sun symbol for Q is to excessive. People may fault the Q as being a sun, and read the logo CIR UE. 3. symbol doesn't convey simplicity and sophistication. 4. symbol doesn't look professional. overall 2/5. your logo #22/ #23 looks much better.
Porteur du Projet
(+) great logo, great creativity, color is very sophisticated.
(-) lack of spacing between cirque and entertainment association needed. it looked too jam packed.
I wonder if you can propose one with another font for the Cirque. I'd love one with 'Q' with a long tail. Also, more vertical spacing between the Cirque and Entertainment association, but not too much.